Lilith Had a Little Hen (110)
This article is a stub. You can help the Piny Institute of New York Wiki by expanding it.
Makeover Nightmare

Makeover Nightmare
Released on September 8, 2017

Read transcript
Legend has it she has only given one A+ to a student: Barry Eatinfield. But, no one belived Barry. After a CIA investigation they found it to be fake; they used Hand Writing Analysis and found he had forged the plus sign. He was never heard from again.

Some say, Barry changed his name and lives on a island where he carved plus signs into shelves, mumbling "A+, A+".

Sam and Will, "Makeover Nightmare"

"Makeover Nightmare" is the ninth episode of the first season of PINY Institute of New York.


Teamwork might make you strong, but when it comes to Michelle and Julia, it's their worst nightmare.


The Indie Girls show off their designs in Mr. Grasso's class and get an A+. The Beautiful People show off their designs in Ms. Montclair's class and also get an A+. The students all go to a classroom for Ms Tilly's makeover class. The students tell a few legends about Ms. Tilly and her class. Ms Tilly enters the class and starts pairing up students for a makeover project. When she pairs Michelle with Julia, Julia asks that she not be partners with her. Then when Michelle and Julia get to work on their model, they begin to argue leading to a horrible makeover job. Ms Tilly then fails both girls, then Michelle asks that they both have a second chance. Ms Tilly agrees and says if they fail again she'll turn them into stone and give them Fs. After class in the Cafeteria Michelle complains about being partners with Julia. Michelle then goes over and talks to Julia about them having to work together, Julia agrees. Afterwards Julia and Michelle do each others makeup, and after another terrible makeup job Michelle agrees to meet Julia in her dorm to work on their team work. When Michelle meets up with Julia in her dorm things go downhill, they begin to argue and exit Julia's room only to find themselves embarresed in front of the entire school. Finally they are back in the classroom for the makeup test. Michelle and Julia both take turns putting makeup on Lisa and end up doing a fabulous job. Ms Tilly compliments their work and gives them both an A++ and they leave the classroom, then after showing off their legit A pluses Julia takes all the credit.


Major Characters

Minor Characters



Click here to view the gallery.
ve Episodes
Season 1
First Impressions (Origins - Part 1)Second Impressions (Origins - Part 2)The SecretFashion BackwardsTo Tutor or Not to TutorFad InBest BloggedCosmaniaMakeover NightmareThe Curse of the BridgeHorsing AroundAmerican MydolSecret-Non-AdmirerPINY Runway Dribble TroubleLabyrinthStupid CupidBella LimaCooking DisasterLonely at the TopLilith Had a Little HenLocked InHire MeFire MeBaby PicsWho Is Michelle?
Season 2
Father's DayGolden TicketThe AuctionCrime of FashionOnce Upon a TimeCoolest Girl in the WorldCatwalk on WaterAnimal AttractionSam Side StoryDownhill SidePlus-OneThe Fake DateJulia's Best DayWardrobe MalfunctionLooking For DoryCold FactsThe Cover UpSkater BoyNo Fun AnymoreJulia QuitsMr. and Mrs. CooperRita Wears NadaSuprise PartyEverybody Hates MeFashion FakeCoffee Girl